Pages

▼

Friday, 19 May 2023

Tarsia Maker

I've written a lot about Tarsia puzzles in the past, and have also made a lot!  There is now a new Tarsia puzzle maker on the block, which I have just been checking out.  It's called Tarsia Maker.


As you can see from this screenshot, there are four different puzzle shapes available:

  1. little triangle - 9 pairs
  2. big triangle - 18 pairs
  3. "lozenge" - 11 pairs
  4. hexagon - 30 pairs
You click on the puzzle shape you want to make, and then it's just a question of typing in your pairs of words or phrases.  You can toggle easily between the boxes by using the Tab button.  Once you've finished typing in your words, just click "Export to PDF" and your puzzle is ready.  The PDF includes the puzzle solution and a link to your puzzle if you want to retrieve and edit it.

So how does it compare to the Formulator Tarsia?  I've compared them and listed the advantages and disadvantages of Tarsia Maker.

Advantages

Disadvantages

  • Web-based – no need to download and install any software

  • Much easier and less time-consuming to type in your words and phrases

  • You can use the “shuffle” button to change the position in the puzzle of your pairs of words/phrases and randomise them.

 

  • Only one font (although it is a clear Arial-type font)

  • Only 4 puzzle types

  • Not possible to have red-herring or extension words/phrases on the puzzle edges

  • Not possible to add images

  • The PDF provides the puzzle and its solution but not the table that Formulator Tarsia provides.

  • Not possible to create dominoes or “follow-me” activities


It looks like there are more disadvantages than advantages, but the advantages are significant and the program's convenience goes a long way to outweighing the disadvantages.

If you're interested in making Tarsia puzzles to use in language lessons, don't forget to have a look at my guide Ideas for using Tarsia.

1 comment:

  1. Your list of drawbacks is what made me read the rest — three of the six
    were exactly what our maths teachers had asked me for.

    I'm not a teacher. I look after IT at an international school in Prague,
    and our maths department came to me with a folder of .fjsw files and a
    growing number of Macs. I ended up building a browser version. The three:

    - More than four types: triangle, hexagon, square grid, dominoes and
    matching cards, each in a range of sizes.
    - Dominoes and follow-me chains: a chain of any length from 6 to 20
    questions, where each tile's answer leads to the next tile's question.
    - Red herrings on the edges: any tiled shape can have its outer edges
    filled instead of left blank. That was our teachers' first complaint
    about every other tool — blank edges tell a student which pieces face
    outwards, and a class that spots it can assemble half the puzzle
    without answering much.

    Three of your points it does not solve, to be straight about it: one
    font, no images, and the PDF is the cut-out pieces plus a solved answer
    key, not the table Formulator Tarsia prints.

    The part I'd most want your readers to know is the bit that started it:
    it opens existing .fjsw files. Formulator Tarsia is Windows-only, so a
    department's collection becomes unopenable on a Mac, Chromebook or iPad.
    This reads them in the browser and reprints them. Nothing is uploaded —
    the file never leaves the machine, which as the person responsible for
    school data I wasn't willing to compromise on.

    Free, no account: https://tarsia.syrovy.tech

    Jakub

    ReplyDelete